10 min read • Published 16 Dec 24
Is Nifty 50 BeES better than Index mutual funds?
Table of Contents
Is Nifty 50 BeES better than Index mutual funds?
Individual stock investments are generally costly and pose several risks. Hence, investors are swayed towards Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) as a safer, less risky, and easier option. Nifty Bees is an ETF that tracks the performance of India’s 50 top companies.
This article answers the question: What is Nifty Bees?
It will also discuss its functionality and analyse its pros and cons. Understanding Nifty Bees enables one to make well-informed choices regarding their investment approach.
What is Nifty Bees ETF?
Nifty Bees is an exchange-traded fund in India that emulates the performance of the Nifty 50 Index. It allows trading like stocks and protects investments like a mutual fund, with the added feature of being traded on the National Stock Exchange.
Every unit of Nifty Bees is a portion of the Nifty 50 index, enabling investors to hit the efficient frontier by holding a basket of the top 50 companies from India. Like stocks, Nifty Bees can be bought and sold in real-time throughout the trading day and are, therefore, a competitive and transparent investment vehicle.
How Does Nifty Bees Work?
Nifty Bees is an ETF designed to track the performance of the Nifty 50 Index rather than outperform it. The fund invests in similar companies, which are constituents of the Nifty 50 index, to realise similar returns.
Such strategies entail acquiring and holding the constituent stocks of the Nifty 50 index to make the ETF’s portfolio closely mirror the index. Nifty Bees makes it easy and cheap for investors to invest in a diversified portfolio of the top 50 Indian companies.
Nifty Bees vs. Other Nifty 50 Investment Options
While Nifty Bees tracks the Nifty 50 index like some mutual funds, there are key differences that might influence one’s investment decision.
Passive vs. Active Management
Nifty Bees employs a passive investment strategy. It aims to replicate the Nifty 50 by acquiring and holding its constituent stocks in the same proportions. This approach offers lower expense ratios compared to actively managed funds that attempt to outperform the market by strategically selecting and weighing stocks.
Trading Flexibility
Unlike many Nifty 50 mutual funds, Nifty Bees units trade on the National Stock Exchange (NSE) throughout the day. This allows for real-time buying and selling during market hours, similar to individual stocks. This provides greater flexibility for investors who want to react to market movements quickly.
Investment Minimums
The minimum investment amount for some actively managed Nifty 50 funds might be higher than that for Nifty Bees. This can be a barrier for new investors who start with smaller amounts.
Tax Implications
Both Nifty Bees and Index Funds have similar tax implications. However, some actively managed funds might have different tax structures depending on their investment strategies.
Is Nifty Bees a Better Alternative?
There is no single “better” option. The choice depends on the investment goals and risk tolerance.
Nifty Bees might be a better fit if:
- One prefers a low-cost, passive investment strategy.
- One values flexibility and wants to trade their holdings in real-time.
- One is a new investor with a smaller starting amount.
Actively managed Nifty 50 funds might be a better fit if:
- One believes in the skill of the fund manager to outperform the market.
- One is comfortable with potentially higher expense ratios.
Comparing Nifty Bees and Nifty 50 Index Fund Investment
Feature | Nifty Bees | Nifty 50 Index Funds |
Investment Strategy | Passive | Passive |
Expense Ratio | Generally lower | Can vary |
Trading Platform | Stock Exchange | Mutual Fund Platform |
Liquidity | High liquidity, real-time trading | Lower liquidity, periodic purchase, and redemption |
Minimum Investment | Lower (can be as low as a single unit) | Can vary, often higher than Nifty Bees |
Dividend Distribution | Does not directly distribute dividends, but capital appreciation is reflected in the unit price | May distribute dividends, depending on the fund’s policy |
Tax Implications | Similar to index funds | Similar to index funds |
Nifty Bees: Core Attributes
Nifty Bees is India’s pioneering exchange-traded fund, launched on December 28, 2001, and is currently managed by Nippon India Mutual Fund. Here are its key features:
1. Diversification
Investors gain exposure to a diversified basket of India’s top 50 companies. It helps reduce risk as the investment is spread across multiple stocks.
2. Low Cost
Nifty Bees, as an ETF, generally has lower expense ratios than actively managed funds. While exact figures can vary over time, Nifty Bees often has an expense ratio in the range of 0.04% to 0.05%. In contrast, actively managed mutual funds, especially those focused on specific sectors or strategies, can have expense ratios ranging from 1% to 3% or even higher. This difference in fees can have a substantial impact on long-term returns, with lower expense ratios leading to higher net returns for investors.
3. Liquidity
Nifty Bees is highly liquid, allowing investors to buy and sell units easily. This ensures that one can enter or exit their investment at their convenience.
4. Real-time NAV
Nifty Bees provides transparent NAV calculations based on real-time NSE trades. Such transparency empowers investors to make informed decisions.
5. Dematerialised Form
Nifty Bees units are traded in a dematerialised form, making it convenient to buy and sell, eliminating the need for physical certificates.
6. Minimum Investment
Nifty Bees is an accessible investment option as it offers a low entry barrier with a minimum investment of ₹10,000.
Benefits of Investing in Nifty Bees
Nifty Bees offers several advantages that make it an attractive investment option for both novice and experienced investors.
Period | Nifty 50 Index (Approximate) | Nifty Bees (Approximate) |
1 Year | 19.16% | Similar to Nifty 50 |
3 Years | 19.42% | Around 19.42% (passive tracking aims to mirror Nifty 50) |
5 Years | 24.12% | Around 24.12% (passive tracking aims to mirror Nifty 50) |
10 Years | Data Unavailable | Estimated 10 Year CAGR: 10% (conservative estimate) 12.54% (based on factsheet data for a similar period) |
20 Years | Data Unavailable | Estimated 20-Year CAGR: 8% (conservative estimate) 11.34% (assuming an average between 10 & 12.54% for 10 years) |
Disclaimer: The information provided is for informational purposes only. PowerUp is not responsible for any errors, omissions, or outcomes related to the use of this information.
Also Note:
- Nifty 50 TRI (Total Return Index) includes reinvested dividends.
- Nifty Bees data is estimated based on its passive tracking nature, which aims to replicate the performance of the Nifty 50 Index.
- The estimates and information is based on historical data. Remember that past performance is not indicative of future results. Market conditions can fluctuate significantly, and investment returns can vary.
1. Simplicity of Investment and Management
In a way, Investing in Nifty Bees is easy and almost the same as buying and selling individual stocks. Investors can buy and sell the units through a demat and trading account, which is affordable to many investors.
Nifty Bees adopts a passive investment policy to replicate the performance of the Nifty 50 Index. This policy reduces the likelihood of human errors that result from active management decisions, eliminating the need to make timely management decisions.
2. Cost-Effective Investment
On average, ETFs such as Nifty Bees have lower expense ratios than managed funds, which has a good influence on returns in the long run. Unlike some mutual funds, Nifty Bees has no exit load, which enables investors to redeem their investments without any extra loader cost.
3. Enhanced Liquidity
Nifty Bees units are capitalised on stock exchanges making the level of liquidity very high. This implies that investors can sell their units without worrying about market liquidity. Investors can buy and sell Nifty Bees units during regular market hours, offering flexibility in their investment strategy.
4. Transparency and Information
Nifty Bees provides transparent information about its holdings. One can easily access details about the underlying stocks in the portfolio, allowing them to make informed decisions. The Net Asset Value (NAV) of Nifty Bees is calculated in real-time, providing investors with up-to-date information on the value of their investment.
Drawbacks of Investing in Nifty Bees
While Nifty Bees offers several advantages, it’s important to acknowledge its limitations:
1. Limited Upside Potential
Tentatively, Nifty Bees seeks to demonstrate the same returns as the Nifty 50 Index instead of outperforming the market. Its returns are bound to the index’s performance, and as a result, there is scope for far better outperformance, particularly in times when the market is very bullish.
2. Excessive Diversification
In as much as over-diversification is necessary for purposes of risk, too much diversification can also be detrimental to earnings. Excessive diversity can prove to be harmful to ones earnings since a large number of companies will weaken the effects of individual stocks on the portfolio as a whole.
3. Tax Implications
An investor who sells their Nifty Bees units within one year from the date of purchase will pay short-term capital gains tax, which can be higher than long-term capital gains tax. For instance, one buys Nifty Bees units worth ₹10,000. After 6 months, they sell them for ₹12,000. Their short-term capital gain is ₹2,000. This ₹2,000 will be taxed at the applicable short-term capital gains tax rate, which is currently 20%.
On the other hand, one buys Nifty Bees units worth ₹10,000. After 2 years, they sell them for ₹15,000. Their long-term capital gain is ₹5,000. This ₹5,000 will be taxed at the applicable long-term capital gains tax rate, which is currently 10%.
Disclaimer: The information provided is for informational purposes only. PowerUp is not responsible for any errors, omissions, or outcomes related to the use of this information.
Also Note: Tax laws are subject to change. Therefore, it is always advisable to consult with a tax professional for the most accurate and up-to-date information.
To Sum Up
Through Nifty Bees, one can effortlessly invest in India’s best companies. Investors who are patient and start small can consider doing SIPs and be able to build up their wealth with time.
However, it is important to monitor one’s investments and the markets. Potential risks include market fluctuations and tracking errors. Such considerations should be well-balanced against targets and the person’s risk appetite.
While it may be acknowledged that very high returns may not be guaranteed with Nifty Bees, the vehicle provides a good basis for wealth-creating over time. It would be prudent to proceed and open a Demat account to take advantage of the Nifty Bees.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Is Nifty Bees a good investment for beginners?
Nifty Bees is a great option for beginner investors and those who want to buy stocks for the first time. It is uncomplicated and inexpensive. It is a practical place to begin for individuals who need to invest their money and seek to do so in a broad range of investment options.
2. What are the risks associated with investing in Nifty Bees?
Although investing in Nifty Bees offers diversification benefits, it is still exposed to market risks. Overall market conditions and the performance of the stocks that constitute the Nifty 50 Index will determine the performance of the ETF.
3. How often are the units of Nifty Bees rebalanced?
Nifty Bees periodically undergoes rebalancing to effectively track the Nifty 50 Index. Owing to this rebalancing, the ETF portfolio is updated according to the index’s latest structure.
4. Can I sell Nifty Bees units anytime?
One may sell their Nifty Bees units at any time through their broker. However, relevant market liquidity and transactional costs should be addressed.
5. What are the tax implications of investing in Nifty Bees?
The Nifty Bees are treated like debt instruments by the government. Hence, they have tax ramifications for the holder. Most of the time, long-term capital gains taxation is lower than short-term capital gains.